• Home
  • Campus
    • Academics
    • Greek Life
    • SGA
    • Student Life
  • State/Local
    • Around Town
    • Board of Regents
    • National
    • Pierre
    • Vermillion City Council
    • Vermillion Police Department
  • Sports
    • Cross Country
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Men’s Basketball
    • Soccer
    • Swimming/Diving
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball
    • Women’s Basketball
  • Verve
    • Feature
    • Diversity
    • Events
    • CAB
    • The Vault
  • Opinion
  • E-Edition
  • COVID-19
The Volante
The Volante
  • Home
  • Campus
    • Academics
    • Greek Life
    • SGA
    • Student Life
  • State/Local
    • Around Town
    • Board of Regents
    • National
    • Pierre
    • Vermillion City Council
    • Vermillion Police Department
  • Sports
    • Cross Country
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Men’s Basketball
    • Soccer
    • Swimming/Diving
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball
    • Women’s Basketball
  • Verve
    • Feature
    • Diversity
    • Events
    • CAB
    • The Vault
  • Opinion
  • E-Edition
  • COVID-19
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
House Bill 1057 does everything but protect trans youthOpinion
Krista Honomichl is a senior majoring in criminal justice and political science. Submitted Photo | The Volante
Home
Opinion

House Bill 1057 does everything but protect trans youth

February 2nd, 2020 Krista Honomichl Opinion comments

Share this story

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest

On Jan. 29, with 46 yeas and 23 nays, HB 1057 passed the SD House of Representatives, and now its fate rests in the SD Senate. Now, with a name like the Vulnerable Child Protection Act, you might be thinking we ought to be protecting our children from the meth epidemic, neglect and abuse and food insecurity.

But this bill addresses none of these issues that plague the lives of South Dakota’s youth. Instead, it unnecessarily encroaches on the doctor-patient relationship in regard to transgender medical care.

HB 1057 would make it a misdemeanor for any medical professional to provide puberty-blocking medications, gender-affirming hormone therapy, or gender-affirming surgery to any minor under the age of 16. This bill is problematic on many levels.

First and foremost, this bill is creating a problem, rather than solving one. It alludes, that children are having major surgeries before they are emotionally and mentally competent to making these decisions. In fact, one legislator, Rep. Jon Hansen (R-25), exclaimed: “We’re talking about injecting little girls…with testosterone. We’re talking about cutting off little girls’ breasts.”

But, The World Professional Association of Transgender Health already recommends transgender youth don’t have gender-affirming surgery until they are at least 18 years old. Corey Brown, vice president of government relations at Sanford Health, noted the Endocrine Society’s guidelines, saying “[surgery] is just not standard practice or done typically on minors.”

SD Planned Parenthood, who started offering gender-affirming hormone therapy in November 2019, does not provide gender-affirming surgery either. They only offer hormone therapy to patients over the age of 16 — with parental consent for patients 16- and 17-years-old.

Proponents of this bill are using inflammatory and emotional claims that contradict fact and reality in an effort to push legislation that would hurt the most vulnerable populations in our state. The reality is individuals who identify as transgender tend to experience higher rates of mental health issues than the general population, with over 50% of transgender youth attempting suicide every year according to the CDC. However, the National Institute of Health and Current Opinion of Pediatricians says, “social and medical gender transition reduces gender dysphoria.”

A couple studies have also showed that access to puberty blockers—a type of reversible medication that pause puberty— has drastically lowered the odds of lifetime suicidal ideation in trans youth. Therefore, the very medication that this proposed bill wants to prohibit is saving lives.

Last but not least, this bill directly contradicts the American principles we hold dearly. Bodily integrity and privacy are at the core of American values; believing the right to self-determination and liberty is essential to a happy, health, and free life. This bill tells all South Dakotan’s, transgender and cisgender people, that our government knows what’s best for them when it comes to their lives, their bodies and their medical decisions.

So, maybe instead being infatuated with the anatomy and gender of children our legislature should be more focused on addressing actual problems in the state of South Dakota, rather than creating new ones.

  • Tags
  • Corey Brown
  • Government
  • House Bill 1057
  • Jon Hansen
  • Krista Honomichl
  • Opinion
  • puberty blockers
  • Rep. Jon Hansen
  • SD Planned Parenthood
  • south dakota
  • The National Institute of Health and Current Opinion of Pediatricians
  • The Volante
  • The World Professional Association of Transgender Health
  • trans
  • trans youth
  • transgender
  • Vulnerable Child Protection Act

Share this story

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest

Krista Honomichl

Related Posts

Creepy Clowns Opinion
March 2nd, 2021

Creepy Clowns

Happy one-year anniversary, COVID: Get tested before spring break Opinion
March 1st, 2021

Happy one-year anniversary, COVID: Get tested before spring break

Soak up the sun Opinion
March 1st, 2021

Soak up the sun

Facebook Comments

Latest Stories

Mar 4th 12:28 PM
Sports

Lee tabbed Coach of the Year, seven players with All-Summit honors

Mar 2nd 5:58 PM
Sports

Coyote volleyball picks up pair of wins at SDSU

Mar 2nd 5:18 PM
Campus

Sustainability department urges students to respond to dining surveys

Mar 2nd 4:19 PM
State/Local

Trans Rights March held in response to House Bill 1217

Mar 2nd 4:07 PM
Sports

Summit League Tournament Preview: Coyote men making adjustments

Mar 2nd 4:06 PM
Sports

Senior women’s basketball players make decisions on extra year of eligibility

Mar 2nd 2:56 PM
Sports

USD women’s basketball ready to make tournament run at the Pentagon

Mar 2nd 2:15 PM
Campus

SGA candidate team preps for voting day

Mar 2nd 1:13 PM
Sports

Coyotes place second, third at Indoor Track Summit League Championships

Mar 2nd 11:57 AM
Campus

USD Symphony Orchestra performs winter concert

Weather

Coyote News

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2K7ERfZmFOg

Advertisement

  • Home
  • Campus
  • State/Local
  • Sports
  • Verve
  • Opinion
  • E-Edition
  • COVID-19
  • Back to top

The Volante

The Volante is the University of South Dakota’s independent student-run newspaper since 1887. Al Neuharth Media Center The Volante 555 N. Dakota Street Vermillion, SD 57069

Advertisement

About

  • About
  • Code of Ethics
  • History
  • Awards
  • Executive Staff
  • Jobs
  • Comment Policy
  • Advertise

Engage

  • Letters to the Editor
  • Contact Us
  • Submit an Overheard
  • Subscribe
  • Submit News Tips

Media Partners

  • Coyote News
  • KAOR 91.1
  • Media & Journalism Department
© The Volante 2015. All rights reserved.