• Home
  • Campus
    • Academics
    • Greek Life
    • SGA
    • Student Life
  • State/Local
    • Around Town
    • Board of Regents
    • National
    • Pierre
    • Vermillion City Council
    • Vermillion Police Department
  • Sports
    • Cross Country
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Men’s Basketball
    • Soccer
    • Swimming/Diving
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball
    • Women’s Basketball
  • Verve
    • Feature
    • Diversity
    • Events
    • CAB
    • The Vault
  • Opinion
  • E-Edition
The Volante
The Volante
  • Home
  • Campus
    • Academics
    • Greek Life
    • SGA
    • Student Life
  • State/Local
    • Around Town
    • Board of Regents
    • National
    • Pierre
    • Vermillion City Council
    • Vermillion Police Department
  • Sports
    • Cross Country
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Men’s Basketball
    • Soccer
    • Swimming/Diving
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball
    • Women’s Basketball
  • Verve
    • Feature
    • Diversity
    • Events
    • CAB
    • The Vault
  • Opinion
  • E-Edition
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
USD economics professor discovers error in South Dakota tobacco measureCampus
Home
Campus

USD economics professor discovers error in South Dakota tobacco measure

September 18th, 2018 Lexi Kerzman Campus comments

Share this story

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest

Travis Letellier, a USD economics professor, discovered an error in the numbers and explanation of a South Dakota measure up for a vote on November 6, 2018.

This election will include five measures and this particular measure covers an increase in taxes on tobacco products to provide financial support to postsecondary technical institutes.

Letellier was giving a presentation at the Vermillion Comber of Commerce conference “Up Next” with political science professor Julia Hellwege explaining each measure. Letellier said four of the ballot measures deal with transparency in the state government and the ethical laws. Letellier said the fifth measure, the one dealing with tobacco taxes, caught his eye.

“I thought when I first started looking at it, it was actually very straightforward because when you look at the ballot, they have what’s called the attorney general explanation,” he said. “It’s kind of a plain language explanation of this is what the ballot will do, and this is if you vote one way, this is what it will mean.”

A teaching point

Letellier said he was initially impressed by the economics in the explanation.

He was so impressed, he wrote down the equation to bring to his freshman classes as a real-world example of the impact of economics.

After attempting to solve the problem himself for three hours, Letellier and Mike Allgrunn, the dean of the economics department, determined the numbers were inaccurate.

The ballot measure will increase the tax on a pack of cigarettes from a $1.53 to $2.53. Taxes would also be increased on wholesale products, such as chewing tobacco and cigars, with an increase from a 35 percent rate to a 55 percent tax. With this increase in taxes, the state is hoping to bring in  25 million dollars in tax revenue.

Letellier said the problem he found is in the description of how the program works, described in the fiscal note.

“The fiscal note says ‘based on previous tax increases, a 65.4 percent increase on price,’” Letellier said. “This is where my brain exploded.”

A problem in the explanation

Levellier said the state is not raising the entire price but is actually raising the tax.

“The problem is when you read the description on the bill it says they want to raise the price 65 percent,” Letellier said “They’re not raising the price on cigarettes, they are raising the tax rate on cigarettes. They are actually raising the price of cigarettes by 16 percent. So when people read this, it says they are raising the price of cigarettes by 65 percent when in reality they are not.”

Letellier said that isn’t the only error in the fiscal note. The fiscal note states that this measure will produce a smoking reduction of 16.4 percent. Letellier said this analysis is based on the elasticity of demand, or how people’s behavior will change due to a price change.

“If you did the economics, you would find that the government is basically assuming that the elasticity of demand for cigarettes is a 0.25 and that is a totally fine number. It says that people who smoke aren’t very affected by price changes and I think that is a fair assumption,” Letellier said.

Letellier said the government had to solve for a variable and work backward in their analysis. They know how much they want to change the price and how much people’s demand will change. He says they need to make sure that enough people will continue to smoke to bring in the $25 million.

The fiscal note states “based on previous tax increases, a 65.4 percent increase in price should produce a smoking production of 16.4 percent.” 

“That’s where their economics completely falls apart,” Letellier said. “They are saying smoking will fall by 16 percent. Here’s their problem: in their description, they are using 64 percent and that’s not the percent change in price. The percent change in price should’ve been the 16.4. This is not the right denominator to use. They used a 64 percent change in the tax rate, not in the price of the product.”

Wholesale product taxes

The description of the measure also talks about the tax change on wholesale products. The descriptions states, “based on the previous tobacco tax increase, a 57.1 percent tax increase is unlikely to affect demand.”

Letellier said this description is confusing because there is no clarification that they switched from talking about cigarettes to wholesale products. Letellier said this description means that tobacco and cigar users’ demand for products would not be affected by a price change at all. This assumption causes an issue in the actual revenue brought in through the tax rais said Letellier. 

“Their assumptions will probably not bring in anywhere near $20 million because they are assuming people will not change their behavior by raising taxes,” Letellier said. “They are assuming they will still be getting all this revenue, the same amount of revenue that they got the last time they raised the taxes on cigarettes.”

Letellier said his concern with this assumption is that elasticity changes over time and tobacco taxes haven’t been raised in South Dakota since 2007.

“There is a different pool of people now and you are changing their tax rate again. I don’t think you can assume that this group of people will have the same reaction as the last group of people did,” Letellier said.

Allgrunn said he believes there is either an error in the explanation or the numbers. He said he predicts the numbers the government projected will not be that far off.

“They made enough mistakes in their math, that by the end they were right,” Allgrunn said. “It bothers me that they are doing economics in public and it’s incorrect. Bless their heart, they are trying to do the right thing and I applaud that. But it does appear to me that there is an error.” 

Allgrunn said South Dakota is one of the top states of predicting tax revenue and that mistakes like this one are uncommon.

“South Dakota to be fair I think a really good job to estimate those taxes, not perfect because nobody is,” Allgrunn said. “South Dakota generally tries to do a really good job at predicting the revenue, sometimes they error a little bit, usually on the conservative side.”

Concerns for voters

Hellwege said her concerns on the political side are that young voters are already critical towards the electoral system, and a mistake like this might cause more people to doubt the system.

“It becomes really challenging when (voters) can’t be confident in the system if the person who is administrating can’t give the right numbers,” Hellwege said. “And what’s worse is that they may carry this negative attitude with them for the rest of their life. We know voting is a habit, and if you don’t develop that habit early on you may never become a regular voter.”

Both Hellwege and Letiller said one of the challenges is often time voters are uneducated on measures they are voting on, and it can be even more challenging now because they may have to question the accuracy of the information given.

“It’s exceptional how rather simple sometimes election administrations information or mistakes can have an enormous effect on our confidence in voting,” Hellwege said. “When we as people become less confident in the elective administrative process, there are many things that make us want to go vote and as we are chipping away at our willingness to vote.”

While Letellier’s original intentions of looking into the economics of this measure was to have his students solve the equation, he is now using it as a teaching point on the importance of being educated on the actual effect economics has on the policy side of politics.

“It is important for students to understand economics so they can’t be fooled by economists,” Letiller said.

  • Tags
  • Featured
  • Trending

Share this story

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest

Lexi Kerzman

Lexi Kerzman is a junior majoring in Media & Journalism and minoring in Business Administration. She is currently the Managing Editor for The Volante. Lexi is originally from Bismarck, North Dakota.

Related Posts

Student Government Association votes against Kevin Hart visit Campus
November 19th, 2019

Student Government Association votes against Kevin Hart visit

Career Closet providing free dress clothes for students Campus
November 19th, 2019

Career Closet providing free dress clothes for students

Graduation and beyond: preparing for the career world early Campus
November 19th, 2019

Graduation and beyond: preparing for the career world early

Facebook Comments

Latest Stories

Dec 10th 1:55 PM
Sports

Coyotes escape Hornets’ sting

Dec 8th 2:14 PM
Sports

Coyote women take gold at SDSU Holiday Open, men take bronze

Dec 6th 10:52 PM
Sports

USD downs Mount Marty at home

Dec 5th 9:21 PM
Sports

Volleyball defeats Central Michigan in first round NIVC win

Dec 4th 11:05 PM
Sports

Women’s basketball defeats Creighton Bluejays 72-65

Nov 24th 12:45 AM
Sports

Coyotes upset Jackrabbits on Senior Day

Nov 24th 12:26 AM
Sports

Coyotes stifle Tigers to remain unbeaten

Nov 23rd 7:58 PM
Sports

Coyotes fall in four to Nebraska-Omaha

Nov 23rd 12:14 AM
Verve

Students share International Experiences during Global Showcase

Nov 19th 10:21 PM
Campus

Student Government Association votes against Kevin Hart visit

Instagram

the_volante

Instagram post 2199198466033768323_10450899735 Coyote volleyball holds off Tulsa in a thrilling 3-1 victory to advance to the NIVC Final. Coach Leanne Williamson announced after the game that the Coyotes will be hosting the final match Dec. 17 at 7:00pm in the SCSC against Georgia Tech. .
📸 - @peyton_beyers • 👩‍💻 - @heidisxhneider
Instagram post 2196044533211607815_10450899735 “hey patrick you know what’s better than 24”
“what”
TWENTY-ONE
.
Coyote women’s basketball moves up 3 spots this week to 21 in the USA Today Coaches Poll. .
📸 - @jacoblindenberg 👩🏽‍💻 - @heidisxhneider
Instagram post 2193019433537362387_10450899735 Coyotes advance to round 2 after winning three straight sets over Central Michigan 3-1 last night. .
They’ll take on UNLV this afternoon at 2pm in the SCSC. UNLV took down UMKC yesterday afternoon to advance. Follow us on twitter for game updates. 📸 - @madilynsindelar
Instagram post 2191136621603566389_10450899735 🚨 | Coyote women’s basketball cracks the top 25 in the USA Today Coaches Poll this week, coming in at 24. .
Last season, the team wasn’t ranked in this poll until the week of Feb. 12. That same week, they debuted in the AP Top 25.
.
📸 - @peyton_beyers 🎨 - @heidisxhneider
Instagram post 2187364686574673537_10450899735 From our family to yours- Happy Thanksgiving.
Instagram post 2183938332281919470_10450899735 For the first time since 2000, Coyote football took down the Jackrabbits. 
@adeloluwa76 captured the historic win. Find us on flickr for more shots!
Instagram post 2182574803972826189_10450899735 Some scenes from the Coyotes’ win over Missouri on Nov. 21. >> Swipe for more >>
📸 - @peyton_beyers
Instagram post 2177055532241107775_10450899735 ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED?!
.
Coyote women’s basketball downed Drake 102-94 in an overtime thriller last night in the SCSC. .
@peyton_beyers and @austinrlammers captured all the action from last night. >>SWIPE>> to check it out and look us up on Flickr to see the full gallery.
Instagram post 2173741637656909836_10450899735 A sweep and a regular season conference title win by Coyote volleyball on Friday night, captured by @peyton_beyers 😍  Look us up on flickr to see the full album.
Instagram post 2162840859757174951_10450899735 Miss the Drag Show on Wednesday? We got you sis. Get swipin’ for more >>>>>>
.
USD Spectrum put on their fall drag show this week, featuring student and professional drag queens and kings.
.
📸 - Miles Amende
Instagram post 2159181697147950200_10450899735 The Nepalese Student Association (NSA) celebrated Dashain, a South Asian celebration symbolizing the victory of good over evil last weekend. Miles Amende captured the celebration. >>> SWIPE >>> for more.
Instagram post 2156133344713431163_10450899735 Eve Weiser is a barista at The Bean in downtown Vermillion. She recently won the Ladies who Latte competition in Minneapolis in September. Check out her story by following the link in our bio!
📸 - @lexi.kerzman
Instagram post 2150982076818986649_10450899735 Kandy Stevens and her family began raising pigeons after one of her children died in a bus crash in 2008. Read this story by following the link in our bio. 📸 - @laurensoulek
Instagram post 2145986760134851858_10450899735 The Heights has been the popular place for students to attend tailgate this year. This has been one of the many different ways students have tailgated before USD football games. Follow the link in our bio to find the history of student tailgate. .
📸 - Maddie Petry
Instagram post 2142193983584219349_10450899735 During D-Days, downtown is flooded with USD students and alumna that return for the festivities. Dakota Brickhouse will be opening their doors early on Saturday to serve a limited breakfast menu equipped with 10 kegs of beer to start off the game day. Follow the link in our bio to read how downtown restaurants prepare for D-Days. 📸 - @peyton_beyers
Instagram post 2141499168177676256_10450899735 Did you get a chance to see the Dr. Pepper National Championship trophy during its stop in Vermillion yesterday? If not, we’ve got the recap right here for you: it was shiny.  It made stops in the MUC and HyVee. Fans got the chance to pose for pictures with it. 
Did we mention it was shiny? 📸 - @peyton_beyers
Instagram post 2137286875864824485_10450899735 @aaron_mercado_official captured An Evening With The Stars this year. >>SWIPE>> for more pictures and follow the link in our bio to read the story behind the event.
Instagram post 2135781925296819305_10450899735 Would you complete a 45-mile bike ride for margaritas at the finish line? Last Saturday, 84 local cyclists did just that. Follow the link in our bio to find out why. 📸 - Chloe Fullenkamp
Instagram post 2135023776864625989_10450899735 Coyote soccer fell to Eastern Washington in a double overtime thriller on Sunday afternoon. They face Drake today, looking to snap a five game loss streak. Follow the link in our bio for the recap of Sunday's game.
📸- Peyton Beyers
Instagram post 2134384957026933735_10450899735 Madilyn Sindelar captured the Coyote volleyball team as they went undefeated in the South Dakota Classic this weekend. They shut down UC Davis and Wyoming 3-0 and 3-1 respectively. They closed out the tournament Saturday night by winning a 5 set thriller against Iowa in front of over 1600 fans. 
They’re back in action on Friday and Saturday in Illinois at the Bradley Classic to close out their non-conference schedule. 📸 - @madilynsindelar
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Weather

Coyote News

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YfKtBw_zsgA

Wake Up Vermillion

https://youtu.be/atIgvHLJb60
  • Home
  • Campus
  • State/Local
  • Sports
  • Verve
  • Opinion
  • E-Edition
  • Back to top

The Volante

The Volante is the University of South Dakota’s independent student-run newspaper since 1887. Al Neuharth Media Center The Volante 555 N. Dakota Street Vermillion, SD 57069

About

  • About
  • Code of Ethics
  • History
  • Awards
  • Executive Staff
  • Jobs
  • Comment Policy
  • Advertise

Engage

  • Letters to the Editor
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe

Media Partners

  • Coyote News
  • KAOR 91.1
  • Media & Journalism Department
© The Volante 2015. All rights reserved.