• Home
  • Campus
    • Academics
    • Greek Life
    • SGA
    • Student Life
  • State/Local
    • Around Town
    • Board of Regents
    • National
    • Pierre
    • Vermillion City Council
    • Vermillion Police Department
  • Sports
    • Cross Country
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Men’s Basketball
    • Soccer
    • Swimming/Diving
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball
    • Women’s Basketball
      • WNIT Championship
  • Verve
    • Feature
    • Diversity
    • Events
    • CAB
    • Verve Blogs
  • Opinion
  • E-Edition
The Volante
The Volante
  • Home
  • Campus
    • Academics
    • Greek Life
    • SGA
    • Student Life
  • State/Local
    • Around Town
    • Board of Regents
    • National
    • Pierre
    • Vermillion City Council
    • Vermillion Police Department
  • Sports
    • Cross Country
    • Football
    • Golf
    • Men’s Basketball
    • Soccer
    • Swimming/Diving
    • Track and Field
    • Volleyball
    • Women’s Basketball
      • WNIT Championship
  • Verve
    • Feature
    • Diversity
    • Events
    • CAB
    • Verve Blogs
  • Opinion
  • E-Edition
  • Follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
USD professors denounce recent science billCampus
The South Dakota State Senate passed a bill in January that opponents say could allow high school science teachers more leeway in how they teach science to students. File photo / The Volante
Home
State/Local
Pierre

USD professors denounce recent science bill

February 21st, 2017 Chance Mullinix Campus, Pierre, State/Local comments

Share this story

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest

A bill that allows school teachers to teach the “strengths and weaknesses” of scientific theories in classrooms, titled “An Act to protect the teaching of certain scientific information,” passed in the South Dakota Senate last month.

The bill, which hasn’t yet been enacted into law, has sparked controversy as a possible defense of teaching creationism in public schools. Various entities, including the state ACLU, as well as various editorials, have been outspoken about their opposition to the bill. 

In full, the bill consists of only one sentence: “No teacher may be prohibited from helping students understand, analyze, critique, or review in an objective scientific manner the strengths and weaknesses of scientific information presented in courses being taught which are aligned with the content standards established pursuant to § 13-3-48.” 

Sam Shaw, an administrator within the division of learning and instruction in the South Dakota Department of Education, said it’s unclear what the bill does.

“The intent seems to be allowing any teacher to teach personal opinions regarding scientific information,” he said. “If the bill does nothing, then it’s unnecessary. If it really does something, then it infringes on the authority and responsibilities of the local school boards to supervise classrooms and direct curriculum. I think, fundamentally, this bill is attempting to fix a problem that doesn’t exist.”

Shaw said there’s no need for the bill because teachers are given leeway to teach what they want, as long as it’s backed up with evidence.

“As of now, science teachers do not need protection if they’re teaching on scientific evidence,” Shaw said.

USD biology professor Hugh Britten said the bill doesn’t really do much, and he questioned why legislators would be in favor of such a bill. 

“Why do we need to waste legislators’ time and everybody else’s time?” Britten said. “The lawsuits are going to be inevitable and the state is going to have to defend them. There’s going to be money, time and effort that’s being wasted all on this one bill.”

While the bill is vaguely-worded, Britten said its real purpose is clear.

“These are weasel-worded bills that come up every once and awhile,” he said. “The strength and weaknesses language is common for creationist bills. You can’t have a law that says x, y and z, you have to fool the legislature.”

Britten said grade school level science should only teach established scientific concepts. 

“My view for pre-college classes is to give students a background in settled science,” Britten said. “Then when they come to college we can start pushing the edges a little bit.”

Cathy Ezrailson, a USD science education professor, said the bill allows teachers to teach their personal opinions in science classrooms.

“It is a bill that espouses to give teachers a choice in how they teach science, that’s the way it’s worded,” she said. “What it does is allows for creationism to be taught alongside science, or instead of science, in public schools. Creationism is a belief system, whereas science is a way of doing and seeing the world. They’re two different things and should not be equated.”

Mark Sweeney, a USD associate professor of Earth sciences, wrote an op-ed in the Argus Leader. He stated, “Previous versions of related bills and in their public statements, the sponsors have clearly indicated their targets: climate change and evolution.”

In an interview, Sweeney said what’s being taught in schools is a set of hard facts, and not off-the-cuff subjects. 

“In K-12 education, I don’t think it helps them when you’re questioning theories,” Sweeney said. “They’re theories because they’ve been tried and tested, over and over again. So it’s not just someone’s opinion. There’s a load of data that back up these ideas.”

Sweeney said he’s frustrated that lawmakers are considering this type of bill when scientific literacy is lacking.

“I think most of us here that teach science at USD are really into science literacy,” he said. “So we want to do what we can to make sure undergraduate students know as much as they can about different science topics.”

There’s little room in science for non-objective, personal agenda-based thinking, Ezrailson said.

“Science has no politics, it has no belief system,” Ezrailson said. “Science is what is observed and recorded, and really, the essence of what is happening. The truth.”

The goal of education is to improve, not impede, students’ education, Sweeney said. This bill would hinder the processes in which students learn science.

“We want to strengthen education, not weaken it,” he said. “We want our students coming out of grade school to have a solid foundation in understanding what scientific concepts are today, based on the evidence we have.”

Share this story

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest

Chance Mullinix

Chance Mullinix is from Sioux Falls and is the sports editor for the Volante. He is pursuing a double major in Media & Journalism and German, with a Film Studies minor. Chance likes sports, movies, TV, video games, the Oxford comma, and talking in the third person.

Related Posts

Sheila Gestring inaugurated as USD's 18th president Campus
February 13th, 2019

Sheila Gestring inaugurated as USD's 18th president

Senate Bill 122 moves past committee hearing, colleges concerned Board of Regents
February 12th, 2019

Senate Bill 122 moves past committee hearing, colleges concerned

Inkpa Mani talks indigenous people, activism and everything art Campus
February 12th, 2019

Inkpa Mani talks indigenous people, activism and everything art

Facebook Comments

Latest Stories

Feb 13th 5:35 PM
Campus

Sheila Gestring inaugurated as USD’s 18th president

Feb 12th 10:38 PM
State/Local

Senate Bill 122 moves past committee hearing, colleges concerned

Feb 12th 8:26 PM
Special

People of the Pack: Kyra Lunde

Feb 12th 8:00 PM
Campus

Inkpa Mani talks indigenous people, activism and everything art

Feb 12th 5:44 PM
Sports

Bilington Breaks Record as Coyotes Split Between Two Meets

Feb 12th 5:14 PM
Campus

High school scholarship recipients visit USD for Top Scholars Day

Feb 12th 5:09 PM
Sports

Inside a distance runner’s mind: Q&A with Eldon Warner

Feb 12th 3:46 PM
Sports

John and Tommy Vining: Brotherhood on the golf course

Feb 12th 3:11 PM
Sports

South Dakota finishes 8th, surpasses Fort Wayne in Martin Downs Collegiate

Feb 12th 12:29 PM
State/Local

Heart Health tips for National Heart Disease Awareness Month

People of the Pack

"I like a lot of music a lot of other people like, so if I’m just playing a lot of loud music to a crowd and getting paid for it, that sounds awesome."
"The nature here is amazing. The Vermillion River, the park, hanging out with my friends and I like cooking."
"I’ve had a couple uncles and a couple aunties come here. My grandmother attended USD in 1970. So they really inspired me and encouraged me to come to USD. They made it sound really awesome and it is an awesome school. I like USD."
"I’m most active with Alpha Phi. We have a lot of philanthropy events like we have our Red Dress Gala, which is just an event we hold every year to raise money for women’s heart health. I’m pretty involved with that, and we also do the Backpack Program where you pack lunches for kids in Clay County."
"After this year I will be doing my MBA after this. Hopefully I can get into a marketing firm and just work my way up. That’s what I’m hoping."
"I find it fun to go to the library in the student-athlete's section. It's nice because you can go there every night. I have been there every night this week just studying and stuff for my test tomorrow."
"USD really cares about its students. They just keep everything really nice here and it’s personal."
"I want to be a politician just for the simple fact of genuinely educating and helping people who don't understand certain policy issues. I want to help them see beyond the biased media so they can research on their own."
"I want to end up being a delivery nurse, anywhere honestly. That’s the end game. I want to travel a lot."
"I want to be a nurse somewhere, but I don’t really know what kind of area. I just want to help people and watch them achieve their goals and get better."
"I just love singing — singing’s my favorite thing to do. It’s always my escape for everything."
"I am going to become a counselor and try to create a safe and welcoming environment. I'll help them where they are, and try to get them where they want to be."
"I very much care for my family and try to take care of them in any way I can. Part of that when I lived in California was trying to take the stress off of my parents. I would do everything around the house: cooking, cleaning, yard work, taking out the trash, grocery shopping."
"I would travel anywhere, I don’t care. I just really like being in new places and meeting new people."
"I can deal with his (stuff), and he can deal with mine. We’ll be up until four in the morning."                         "We’re just social people, we like to talk and have a good time."
"I’ve definitely met people who are more free-spirited and not judgmental and more interested in the same things as I am. I studied abroad last summer in Ireland."
"(If I could go back) I would’ve stuck with basketball and played basketball in college. I just feel like I missed out on an opportunity. I still could’ve gotten a business degree while playing basketball. I just wish I would’ve worked harder at it. I played at first and then I quit. I signed at USF, University of Sioux Falls. I played summer ball with them, with their team, so I didn’t get to experience the full effect."
"I don’t think I’d change anything, because then if I changed something then something else wouldn’t have happened. Why change? My life is pretty good right now. Life is completely about perspective."
"My favorite artist is my band, Bread of Stone. We are growing up with Christian music and we have a lot of shows too. We already have a couple albums out."
"I was a sophomore in high school when my grandma Betty passed away, and it was two years before that when my grandpa Walter passed away. I don’t remember much of Betty because she had Alzheimer’s, so we would go see her once or twice a year in her home. I know that she liked to bake a lot. She would bake all kinds of things — cookies, pies, cakes. She was known for her little tea parties when we came over. The only thing I remember is her sitting in the back porch with my grandpa when we would go to visit them before they both moved to homes. I remember lots of my grandpa. He was a fiery, grumpy old man. He used to give us Sunkists and cookies every time we went to see him. We’d bring him meals when he still lived in his house, and later when he had moved, we would take him to church every Sunday and go for hour long drives that he loved and we all had to suffer through."

Weather

  • Home
  • Campus
  • State/Local
  • Sports
  • Verve
  • Opinion
  • E-Edition
  • Back to top

The Volante

The Volante is the University of South Dakota’s independent student-run newspaper since 1887. Al Neuharth Media Center The Volante 555 N. Dakota Street Vermillion, SD 57069

About

  • About
  • Code of Ethics
  • History
  • Awards
  • Executive Staff
  • Jobs
  • Comment Policy
  • Apply
  • Advertise

Engage

  • News Tips
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Overheard Submission
  • In The Know & In The Dark
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe

Media Partners

  • KYOT-TV
  • KAOR-FM
  • Coyote Communication
  • Coyote Creative
  • Media & Journalism Department
© The Volante 2015. All rights reserved.